Why I’m Writing About Toilet Paper
Look, I know reviewing toilet paper seems ridiculous. But after the great TP shortage of a few years back, I started paying more attention to what we were actually buying. When you’re stuck with sandpaper-grade tissue for three months, you develop opinions.
Scott ComfortPlus has been our household standard for about a year now. Here’s why.
Quick Specs
| Feature | Details |
|---|---|
| Type | ComfortPlus |
| Quantity | 24 rolls |
| Ply | 2-ply |
| Pack Type | Family pack |
| Scented | Unscented |
The Goldilocks Zone
There are basically three categories of toilet paper: cheap and scratchy, expensive and luxurious, and somewhere in the middle. Scott ComfortPlus lives in that middle zone.
Is it as soft as Charmin Ultra? No. But it’s also not going to dissolve in your hand or feel like you’re using a paper towel. For a household that goes through toilet paper at a reasonable pace, this hits the balance of “comfortable enough” and “won’t empty your wallet.”
My septic tank guy (yes, I have a septic tank guy) actually recommended Scott because it breaks down better than the ultra-plush options. Apparently the super soft stuff can cause issues. So there’s that.
Strength vs. Softness
The 2-ply construction holds up fine. I’ve never had it fall apart mid-use, which is more than I can say for some generic brands we tried. It’s not going to win any awards, but it does its job without drama.
Wet strength is decent - not amazing, but adequate. If you’re used to the really premium stuff, this might feel like a downgrade. If you’re coming from budget tissue, it’ll feel like an upgrade.
Value Breakdown
The 24-roll pack is where the value is. Buying single rolls or small packs of premium brands costs significantly more per square foot. I did the math once when I was bored (don’t judge me), and this pack works out to roughly half the cost per roll compared to Charmin Ultra Soft.
The upfront cost is higher than grabbing a 4-pack, obviously. But if you have the storage space, buying in bulk makes sense. We keep ours in the hall closet and restock every couple months.
The Environmental Angle
Scott gets some credit here. They’ve got FSC certification and have made noise about responsible sourcing. The packaging is still plastic, which isn’t ideal, but the actual product comes from managed forests.
If environmental impact is your primary concern, there are 100% recycled options that perform similarly. But for mainstream brands, Scott does better than most.
Who This Works For
Families - The bulk pack makes sense when you’re going through rolls quickly.
Septic systems - Breaks down better than the ultra-soft competition.
Budget-conscious shoppers - Good quality for the price point.
People who want “good enough” - Not the best, not the worst, just reliable.
Who Might Want Something Else
Sensitive skin - If you need the softest possible option, Charmin or Cottonelle might be worth the premium.
Luxury seekers - This is practical, not pampering.
Very tight budgets - Store brands are cheaper, though quality varies wildly.
Comparison to Alternatives
| Feature | Scott ComfortPlus | Charmin Ultra | Cottonelle |
|---|---|---|---|
| Softness | Good | Very soft | Very soft |
| Strength | Strong | Medium | Strong |
| Pack Size | 24 rolls | Varies | Varies |
| Price | Moderate | Higher | Higher |
| Septic Safe | Yes | Kind of | Yes |
Final Thoughts
Scott ComfortPlus isn’t exciting. It’s toilet paper - it’s not supposed to be exciting. What it is: reliable, reasonably priced, and comfortable enough that nobody in my household has complained. After trying various brands over the years, we’ve settled here and haven’t looked back.
The 24-roll family pack is the way to go if you have storage space. Subscribe-and-save deals make it even cheaper if you’re willing to commit.
The bottom line: Solid everyday toilet paper that won’t break the bank or disappoint. Sometimes boring and reliable is exactly what you want.
Prices and availability change. Check current deals before purchasing.